Armed vs Unarmed Security Guards: Which Is Right for You?

When it comes to hiring security, hiring the right type of personnel is one of the most important decisions to consider before starting. A question many organizations typically face is whether they need armed security guards or unarmed security guards.

‍

Both options provide professional protection, but both options are better suited for different environments, risks profile, and business needs.

‍

In this article, we’ll break down the key differences between armed and unarmed security guards, explore when each is most effective based on the specific situation, and help you make an informed and educated decision about your company’s security plan.

‍

‍

What’s the Difference Between Armed and Unarmed Security Guards?

‍

The main distinction between armed and unarmed guards is actually quite simple.

‍

Armed guards carry a firearm, while unarmed guards do not. That’s really it. 

‍

However, this simple difference extends into the many different types of training, licensing, and the duties they perform.

‍

• Armed Security Guards are licensed professionals who have undergone specialized firearms training and meet strict state or federal regulations. Along with traditional security skills, they are also trained to responsibly carry and, if necessary, use firearms in defense of people or property. Their presence alone often acts as a strong deterrent to criminal activity.
  
• Unarmed Security Guards provide protection without firearms, but that doesn’t make them less effective. They are trained in surveillance, de-escalation techniques, access control, and emergency response. Their focus is on preventing and deterring crime through visibility, communication, and rapid reporting to law enforcement when necessary.
  

‍

When Should You Use Armed Security Guards?

‍

Armed guards are most effective in environments where there is a higher risk of violence, theft, or valuable assets at stake. Essentially, the more potential risk of violence and loss of expensive property or assets, armed security guards are usually present. 

‍

Businesses typically hire armed guards in situations such as:

‍

• Financial Institutions – Banks, credit unions, or cash-handling facilities often require armed security due to the risk of robbery.
  
• High-Value Retail Stores – Jewelry stores, luxury boutiques, or electronics retailers benefit from the additional deterrent that armed guards provide.
  
• Corporate Offices or Executives – High-profile companies or executives may require armed protection for personal safety.
  
• Large Public Events – Concerts, political events, or sporting venues where crowds can create volatile situations and potentially dangerous.
  
• Industrial or Warehouse Sites – Facilities storing expensive equipment, pharmaceuticals, or sensitive materials often hire armed security to prevent theft.
  

In short, if your business faces serious security threats or handles high-value assets, armed security is often the right solution.

‍

‍

When Are Unarmed Security Guards the Right Choice?

‍

Not every business requires armed protection. In fact, in many situations, unarmed security guards are the ideal choice. They provide a professional presence without the potential concerns and threatening appearance that can sometimes come with firearms.

‍

Common use situations for unarmed guards include:

‍

• Office Buildings – Monitoring access points, assisting tenants, and maintaining a safe, friendly, and professional environment.
  
• Schools and Campuses – Creating a safe atmosphere for students and staff without introducing firearms unless absolutely necessary.
  
• Healthcare Facilities – Managing patient and visitor flow, de-escalating tense situations, and assisting medical staff in emergencies.
  
• Retail Stores – Preventing shoplifting, ensuring employee safety, performing loss prevention, and responding quickly to suspicious behavior.
  
• Hospitality & Residential Communities – Hotels, apartment complexes, and gated communities often prefer unarmed guards for their balance of security, approachability, and customer service.
  

For businesses that primarily need visibility, deterrence, customer service, and incident reporting, unarmed guards provide reliable and cost-effective protection.

‍

‍

Duties of Armed vs. Unarmed Guards

‍

While both types of guards share many responsibilities, the scope of their duties can vary:

‍

Armed Security Guard Duties

‍

• Protect high-risk areas and deter serious and potentially violent criminal activity
• Protect high profile individuals from serious violent criminal activity
• Patrol sites with valuable assets or sensitive materials
• Respond to active threats where force may be required
• Maintain strict firearm safety protocols
• Often coordinate directly with law enforcement during emergencies
  

Unarmed Security Guards

‍

• Monitor surveillance cameras and patrol properties
• Control access to buildings and restricted areas
• Provide customer service and visitor assistance
• Write incident reports and notify police when needed
• Handle crowd control and de-escalate conflicts
  

Both roles focus on prevention first—armed guards simply add an additional layer of defense in case of high-risk threats.

‍

‍

Key Considerations When Deciding

‍

When choosing between armed and unarmed security guards, ask yourself the following questions:

‍

1. What kind of risks does my business face? – Are you more likely to encounter theft, vandalism, or violent crime? Or do you just need visibility and non-violent deterrence from crime?
   
2. What image do I want to project? – Armed guards can deter threats but may feel intimidating in customer-facing settings. Unarmed guards bring a less threatening appearance and can offer a positive experience and customer support.
   
3. What is my budget? – Armed guards typically cost more due to licensing, training, and insurance requirements. Unarmed typically cost less, due to less specialized training.
   
4. Do I need deterrence or response? – Unarmed guards are highly effective for prevention and customer interaction, while armed guards are best suited for higher-level threats.
   

By understanding your security risks and business environment, you’ll ensure you’re investing in the right level of protection.

‍

‍

The Bottom Line

‍

Both armed and unarmed security guards play a critical role in keeping people, property and public spaces safe. The right choice depends on your business’s unique needs, the risks you face, and the environment you want to maintain.

‍

At Members In Black Private Security, we specialize in helping businesses assess their security requirements and implement customized solutions for their situations. While we primarily provide unarmed security guard services for our clients, we sometimes do provide armed guard services for specific clients.

‍

No matter what your situation or security needs, our team is able to provide reliable, trained, and licensed professionals to keep you and your business safe.

‍

Ready to Strengthen Your Security?

‍

If you’re unsure whether armed or unarmed security is right for you, our team can help you evaluate your risks and recommend the best solution.

‍

Contact us today to schedule a consultation and learn how our security services can protect what matters most.